Are They Necessary?
|
Posted on 4 March 1999
The following text was written by Shane
Burgess: I have talked with many fellow classmates and college professors
about using graphing calculators. Some of the questions I asked were as simple as "which
one should I get?" and some were as complex as how to use specific functions on a certain
calculator. But, if a class really doesn't need a graphing calculator, and the instructor
doesn't support their use in a class, then they may just get in the way. Especially if the
user is playing games during class time. Most of the math instructors at the
community college I attend require the use of graphing calculators. This is great, for it
has been proven that when graphing calculators are in the curriculum, they do indeed help
the students understand the necessary concepts faster and more efficiently. They are a tool,
a very powerful tool, and they should not be abused. Graphing Calculators were
designed to help students grasp the concepts of Algebra, Algebra II, and other graphing
concepts. Even though they are capable of playing games, that is not what they were meant
for. Playing games while in a class will be distraction, a disturbance to others, and slow
done the lesson for the class. Many instructors are aware of the fact graphing calculators
can play games, and they won't allow them for the lesson or for the entire class. This is
not what we want to happen. Graphing calculators are an essential tool for
learning difficult concepts. I applaud the teachers that feel as strong as I do about them.
If a student is only playing games on their calculator, then maybe they should have the
privilige of using a calculator taken away. That's correct, using a graphing calculator is a
privilige, not a right. A student can fight and moan about losing their calculator, but if
they were misusing the "tool" then it is fair. Graphing calculator games are great
and a lot of fun. It is okay to have them on the calculator, but to avoid any possible
conflicts, try to follow these general guidlines: - DO NOT play games during
a lecture or during an important lesson. No matter how boring.
- Use the calculator only
when the instructor allows. If the instructor says no calculators, then put the
calculator(s) away.
- Spend more time taking notes by hand and listening to the instructor
during lectures. If you use your calculator to take notes, then type them up after class. It
can be a distraction to others if you are "flaunting" your calculator to take notes.
- If
you are in a class that doesn't require graphing calculators as part of the lesson, PUT IT
AWAY!! Again, this can be a distraction for the user and the surrounding people.
- If you
must play games, play them when you have the time. If you have a test to study for, save the
games for later. Wait until you have the time.
- Graphing calculators are tools. Respect
that, and if necessary, remove the games if they are getting to be too much of a
distraction. Use the calculator for what it was intended.
|
|
Reply to this item
|
Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
billybobIV
(Web Page)
|
I AGREE WITH THIS GUY. Ok, I play games in class. I only play if i get to class a little early, if I finish the assignment early, or maybe if the teacher is helping someone else individually.
What I think is NOT ACCEPTABLE is when your playing games and then the teacher looks right at you and you know that they want you to listen. This causes a disruption because then the people next to you will look over to see what you're doing. If the teacher has to come and reset your calc then you should not be allowed to bring your calc to class again.
Play games only when the teacher isn't trying to teach or when he's helping an individual.
REMEMBER you have the right to the pursuit of happiness however you please (playing games) as long as it doesn't infringe on someone else's rights. If the teacher deems the calc games as a distraction to him then you're infringing on the other students right to get the teaching that our taxes pay for.
*I know I sound like someone's mother, but I feel in a kind lecture givin mood tonight!*
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 05:43 GMT
|
|
|
|
|
Re: Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
Jude M.
(Web Page)
|
" I AGREE WITH THIS GUY. Ok, I play games in class. I only play if i get to class a little early, if I finish
the assignment early, or maybe if the teacher is helping someone else individually. "
That's nice.
" What I think is NOT ACCEPTABLE is when your playing games and then the teacher looks right at you
and you know that they want you to listen. This causes a disruption because then the people next to
you will look over to see what you're doing. "
Care to explain /why/ you don't think it's acceptable? A disruption in class isn't the product of my action, it's the product of the teacher's reaction and thus not my responsiblity. There would be no disruption without the teacher's action.
" If the teacher has to come and reset your calc then you
should not be allowed to bring your calc to class again. "
Yeah, zero tolerance policies work so well, don't they?
Does this include math class?
Why do _you_ get to decide where _my_ calculator should be?
" Play games only when the teacher isn't trying to teach or when he's helping an individual. "
What about games started while such is the case, but not done before such is no longer the case?
" REMEMBER you have the right to the pursuit of happiness however you please (playing games) as long
as it doesn't infringe on someone else's rights."
Actually, I don't have that right specifically guaranteed me. The Declaration of Independence has no legal weight. I could also mention not everyone is necessarily from the U.S.
" If the teacher deems the calc games as a distraction to
him then you're infringing on the other students right to get the teaching that our taxes pay for. "
You're taxes don't pay for my education, those of other private school students, or those residing in countries other than the U.S. In addition, my infringement is not arbitrated by the teacher. they have no standing to make such a judgement, enforce it, or have any force behind it.
" *I know I sound like someone's mother, but I feel in a kind lecture givin mood tonight!* "
So did I.
|
Reply to this comment
|
1 August 2001, 09:35 GMT
|
|
my 2 cents
|
RocketMan
|
well, No to the no game in school idea. First games wil live on forever. Two teachers will NOT remove graphing calc's. Three school sucks that's why the games were created. If we lived in a perfict world yes we would all have our nose in the book and a pocket protector. But for the real world there is games I don't know about you but if you are good enugh to keep a b in AP calcu-care-less and play games at the same time long live Tetris and all the other games that the goverment is letting me play under there roof.
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 05:48 GMT
|
|
Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
Wingman
|
Yeah, I've learned more and used more math porgramming and playing games than I do in Algebra 2! I think that games on calcs are great and are the main thing thats kept this "TI Community" alive and thriving!
LONG LIVE CALC GAMES!!!
--Wingman
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 07:08 GMT
|
|
Games don''t always distract
|
Weiss
|
I can play galaxain and listen to class discussion at the same time. But games like "Fast Tunnel" do distract.
And, blaming calulators for all problems is just dumb.
Right in the TI82/83 manual the following text is stated:
"<B>getKey</B> returns a number corresponding to the last key presses.....Use <B>getKey</B> inside loops to transfer control, for example, when creating video games."
Video games are mentioned right in the manual.
The folks at TI had games in mind when designing the >=TI82 calculators.
If all we needed was math, we'd buy TI80's.
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 07:31 GMT
|
|
Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
Jimmy Conner
(Web Page)
|
I completely disagree with your article. Its things like the calculator that were made in class when people were so bored that they couldn't stand it. Same goes with the games. Before assembly came along, at least 90% of all games were made in class. Thats where we are trained to think the most and thats where we do are best.
As for playing games in class, it really isn't your responsibility or right to tell others what to do. They make their own choices. Next, your going to tell me to quit showing up to 8am Calculus drunk. And like ppl playing games in class, this will never stop. lol
Jimmy
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 07:36 GMT
|
|
Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
Paul Zeman
|
Nice article Shane! Though undoubtedly your article will not change anything, it does succeed in showing just how immature and ignorant the majority of the people are on this board. Look people, you're at school to learn. You are required by law to attend classes. We the tax payers are not dishing out a pretty penny just so you lazy asses can sit and play your little calculator games throughout classes. Oh wow, big deal, you got a 4.0! Wow, we are really proud of you! It still is no excuse. Teachers spend many hours preparing for lectures, and have dedicated their lives to teaching. Show them some respect and pay attention. Christ, just imagine what you people could do if you put forth an effort. You are all obviously very smart kids, just lazy. Don't distract your teachers and the rest of the class just because you can't find enough power inside yourselves to make it through 1 hour without the stimulation of a cheap calculator game. I played calculator games upon getting my new ti85. I was one of the first people in my school to get the graphlink cable. But I realized it wasn't worth it. It may be tough to pull yourself away at first, but after a little while, the temptation to play games will be gone. Play during before classes and lunch. This was plenty enough stimulation for me. If you can't pay attention for more then one hour you're in for a lot of trouble in the future. And once you get to college kiss that calculator goodbye! You'll be lucky if you even have the time to play a game of z-cart before class.
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 16:38 GMT
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Re: Re: Re: Article: "Are They Necessary?"
|
Paul Zeman
|
I mean in class, kiss your calculator goodbye in class. In all of my classes, calculators are not allowed, and you go so fast that you won't have time to play games in class. I am not against calculators!!!! I programmed some z80 assembly, and now after taking computer architecture, I am going to learn some assembly to program my ti89, and restart a game I started a year or 2 ago. I am entitled to my opinion. In high school, the people who played games all throughout class were some of the laziest people i have met. I think its just an indication of laziness if you can't pay attention for 1 hr. You are entitled to your own opinion, and I mine. If you want to piddle away your intelligence, hey, thats fine. No loss to me.
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 23:03 GMT
|
|
D.O.R.K.S.
|
TheTalkingFish
(Web Page)
|
You guys are the biggest bunch of goobers. Why the hell would anyone buy a link cable if not to play games on the calc?
And what is wrong with playing games. You say: "It distracts from school work" ...pretty lame, guys.....
|
Reply to this comment
|
4 March 1999, 17:43 GMT
|
|
|
|
|
Re: D.O.R.K.S.
|
TI-89 User
|
You, Mr. Talking Fish, are the D.O.R.K. who has no clue what you are talking about. Link cables, both calc-to-calc link cables (which, Mr. Talking Fish, happen to come with the calculator when you buy it) and Graph-Link cables have other uses than games. The main use I have for my graph link cable is to back up the memory on my TI-89. That way, if it somehow is accidentally erased, I can restore it. It is also useful whenever I get the urge to attempt to write a program to be able to type it in on my computer, rather than the calculator's keyboard. I use my calc-to-calc cable to transfer files from my calc to friends calcs. I had a friend whose source code on his 89 got messed up and the factor feature wouldn't work. We had an algebra test that day. So, I used my link cable to send him the proper code. So, while both the graph-link and calc-to-calc cables CAN be used for gaming, they can also be used for many other constructive purposes.
|
Reply to this comment
|
6 March 1999, 04:17 GMT
|
|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
You can change the number of comments per page in Account Preferences.
|