ticalc.org
Basics Archives Community Services Programming
Hardware Help About Search Your Account
   Home :: Community :: Articles :: Put the Calculator Away!
Put the Calculator Away!

Posted on 19 November 1998

The following text was written by Jimi:

Consider the following example: You’re sitting in the back of your English class. It’s boring and seems like it’s never going to end. You look at the clock. There’s still 15 minutes left to the class, so you decide to pull out your TI85 and play a game of Galaxian or two, and so you quietly do so, hiding the calculator behind your book bag. You get so into the game that you fail to notice the teacher is walking down the aisle toward you, wondering why you’re not watching the board at all. You finally notice when the teacher calls on you to answer a question. In panic you stuff the TI-85 under your book bag to cover it, but your teacher takes note of your actions and realizes what you’re doing. "Put the calculator away," you’re caught. The batteries are pulled from the calculator and you may have to wait a day to get it back.

This is a common scene at many high schools around the nation, and for this reason, many teachers look down upon the Texas Instruments graphing calculators, seeing them as frequent toys and seldom academic tools. Teachers in all education departments are aware of the gaming capabilities. Texas Instruments has remained far from openly advocating implementation. They have, although, put built-in assembly language support in several of their more recent calculators, but do most Calculator Based Laboratories need assembly support? Do you need 98 kilobytes of RAM to solve linear equations? Probably not. Texas Instruments is only aiding the gamer by adding these features. There is no real need other than better graphics, faster ray-casting, faster RPG, more levels, more games, and room still to have all your Calculator Based Laboratories and data.

There are many students who get perfectly decent grades and deserve to goof off in class a little. But there are many students who are struggling and games only serve as an added distraction.

If calculator gaming is continued at this scale, teachers will take away calculator privileges and gear their class labs, assignments, and studies toward calculators without the gaming functionality. Students need to realize that there is a time to play and a time not to play. If games on calculators lose their usability they will die off. There will be no programmers popping up with the aspiration to become great if there is no need for calculator based games.

We will see new generations of calculators designed with the sole purpose of math and science applications only. Texas Instruments calculator games will be novelties and antiques if the current situation continues. Something must be done!

  Reply to this item

Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Ahmed El-Helw
(Web Page)

I agree that you have a really good point. I personally take my TI to school even though I don't have math - calculating grades, etc. However, I do play games, but not in the middle of academic classes. Things like PE when we are allowed to do whatever we want or AP Computer Science when we finish our work 10 days early are good periods for playing on our calcs.. Still though, talking is more fun :)

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 12:26 GMT

Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
deadbattery
(Web Page)

Thinking back to my history with TI Graphing Calculators, I can't really say that I have ever played games during classtime in school. I can say however that the calculators aren't really a help to me, academically, because they are not allowed on exams and quizzes -- Even moreso in college. I cannot use my TI 85, TI92, or TI92+ on any exam or quiz in college. Everything has to be done in your head and on paper if you want to do actual math - which makes it hard to find the TRIG function of some really odd number.

Anyways, I really have never played games until I recently (three months ago) obtained my TI 92 and played my fav game, Tetris. I love the graphics, that's all I can say about that!

I do enjoy playing games on my calculator and I don't think it's fair/right for teachers to take the calculators away from the students, but the students shouldn't be playing them during academic courses unless the class is completely finished.

I have never had a problem with a teacher taking my TI 85 away in highschool. Actually they were all amazed at it's progammability both in Asm and in Basic - they supported me insead.

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 13:08 GMT

Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Troy Kellogg
(Web Page)

In this country we supposedly have the freedom of choice. Thus we should have the choice to listen or not in class; if one is playing a claculator game in class the teacher should be happy that that person is not disrupting. Teachers should be more accepting of this versital tool. There is no point in taking away your calcualator and getting all worked up about "those Damn TI claculators", for a few reasons #1) it leaves you with less to do so then you find yourself talking to a friend next to you thus disrupting others learning #2) It is your right to quitely not listen #3) where in sam hell did teachers think they got the right to take things away from you that have no other disruption effect on than you IT's YOUR CHOICE to listen or or not listen to learn or not learn in school.
-Troy

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 13:20 GMT

Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Nat Sith

I totally agree!! I think that teachers shouldn't have the right to fuss with students as long as it doesn't affect others. I think teachers are there to teach regardless of whether students learn or not.

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 21:45 GMT


Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Chris Fazio

Your right! Teachers shouldn't care if students are playing calc games in class! It's our education and I feel we have the obligation to ruin it if we want. And not that calc games would ruin our education anyway! As long as you are not playing them during IMPORTANT parts of the class, who cares? Teachers should be happy that we can program at all. Programming is more interesting and more important than alot of than the stuff they teach us, anyway!

Reply to this comment    1 July 1999, 23:35 GMT

Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Nathan Ernst

In case you haven't noticed, many of our personal freedoms have already been sacrificed "to maintain the order and discipline of the institution." So, although you can choose not to listen, the teacher can also tell you to put away your calculator. For the same reason schools have dress codes (although at my school it is limited to no offensive sayings or suggestions on clothing along with a few other things). Schools can also tell you not to curse or swear or use certain phrases and words like "shut up" or "crap" or "suck." This a blatant suspension of the first amendment. You also cannot bring a firearm onto school grounds, despite our right to keep and bear arms (second amendment). We also do not have the right to due process in schools (fifth amendment). The Supreme Court has ruled on this before and has stated that it is okay to suspend certain personal freedoms in schools for the better good.

Do you get the point in that the teachers are in fact able to suspend our personal freedom dealing with the use of our calculator priveleges (among other things)in their class?

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 22:33 GMT

Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Kenney

That's entirely correct. Who is being referred to in the phrase "All men are created equal?" At the time it was only white men over the age of 18. The constitution wasn't written with anyone else in mind, such as women or blacks. Black votes were considered 2/3 of a person, and women couldn't vote. Those things have changed but the age still applies, today you really don't have any constitutional rights until your 18, like personal freedom or voting.
And if you don't live in the united states never mind.

Reply to this comment    20 November 1998, 00:56 GMT


Re: Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
X

Wandering a bit off of the subject now, arent we?

Reply to this comment    21 November 1998, 04:19 GMT

Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Aaron

Oh, we have a freedom of choice eh? So i can CHOOSE to go and kill someone or rob a bank today and I can't get in trouble because i'm protected under our constitutional right to choice. Cool

Reply to this comment    21 November 1998, 20:13 GMT


Re: Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
ungod
(Web Page)

yeah, you can choose to do that. Just remember that the authorities can choose to kill you or imprion you if you make a choice they don't like.

Reply to this comment    26 November 1998, 23:57 GMT


The logical question....
Piloter

Explain to me, somebody, why you cannot express a strong feeling in words other than 4-letter anglo-saxon expletives? Postulate I wish to express my distaste for a homework assignment. I could say "This sucks," or I could say "This is pointless and trivial, an utter waste of my time".
Please note that the latter is not only more expressive but also does not violate conventional rules of politeness.
Also, may I inquire why one would want to carry a firearm to school? In the first place, to follow the law, you would have to be 21 in order to have purchased a firearm. How many graduate students carry guns, I wonder? And how many high-schoolers, grade-schoolers, or even many college students have the maturity to carry a firearm and to avoid using it for trivial purposes? Or, could we be seeing the school hallways chosen as the next gang-war battlefield? About the freedom...anybody here read John Locke's theories? (I think it was him) about how individuals choose to give up certain freedoms in order to gain greater benefits from the organization they sacrifice to? School is a privilege, not a right. (For some reason, I can sense the flames already. *shrug*)
$.02.
--Piloter

Reply to this comment    21 November 1998, 21:45 GMT


Re: The logical question....
AKABudman

NO you are wrong school is a right otherwise there wouldnt be any public schools. And also contrary to poular belief the majority of american schools are not war zones and only a small fraction of the student population carries any form of weapon to school. how do i know well i have attended school which people have classified as "gang" schools. And again contrary to popular belief not all people feel the need to use an expletive every other word. I dont know what your background is but you dont seem to know how most people (or at least of the ones i know) truly behave and act

Reply to this comment    25 November 1998, 01:59 GMT


Re: Re: The logical question....
Olathe  Account Info
(Web Page)

That is incorrect logic. Public schools are not a "right", they are a want that is provided by the public through taxes. You don't need schools. People could survive without them, as people did, and do now, without schools.

Reply to this comment    19 August 1999, 09:58 GMT

Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Nofx

The teachers are trying to keep kids from wasting their lifes away playing games. I admit, I have no self control and I play games during math and physics (never in any others). Sometimes I wish my teacher would say something just so I would know he even notices im in his class. A good teacher is one who trys to keep his students focused. Any teacher who is taking away a calc is doing so becuase they care enough about their students to want them to learn and pass the class with a good grade.

Reply to this comment    20 November 1998, 00:28 GMT

Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Bellman
(Web Page)

Bullsh*t. Students should have the sole right to decide whether they pay attention or not. If they dont know their crap they will be punished by bad test grades, if the do then there is no need for them to listen.

Reply to this comment    22 November 1998, 03:31 GMT


Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Olathe  Account Info
(Web Page)

Wasting their life away playing games ??? I don't think there are many cases of people who played games a lot in high school, and later became bums who lived to play video games.

Reply to this comment    19 August 1999, 10:00 GMT


Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Matt Olson

I agree, why do they care if you are not disrupting anyone? Also, where do teachers get the right to take away our stuff?

Reply to this comment    22 November 1998, 00:22 GMT

Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Chernobyl

BS! Yeah, like the calculators aren't considered academic tools since we play games on theme. Second of all, teachers don't look down on these calculators because we play games on them, its one of those never ending wars between us and them. And they are by no means going to stop us. Any why did TI put 94k of mem on a calc, programs, obviously. Yes, it is possible to have a lotta Math and Science stuff, but TI also realizes that we want memory for GAMES!!! Even if you get your memory erased, its not that hard to get MORE games, especially now with utilities like Mem-Locking and a greater percentage of people with the Graph-Link. So, lamer, stop fighting for the teachers, GAMES FOR EVER!!!

Reply to this comment    19 November 1998, 13:36 GMT

Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Sean Laurvick

Dude, grow up! Seriously, the "us vs. them" thing has gone too far. They're not out to get us! If teachers really cared about us playing games in their classes, they'd do something about it. In my English class, for example, the teacher will issue a warning if he even SEES a TI calc, because he knows that they have nothing to do with English. The next offense gets it taken away, to be picked up at the end of the period. That's all. They have nothing against us personally, it's simply their job to make you want to learn.

Another thing; If you insist on the never-ending war against the adult world, here's a news flash: YOU WILL LOSE!! They're older, have more authority, probably know more than you do, can earn more money, and, if it cames to an all-out brawl, they're bigger than we are. So lighten up! Try agreeing with the teachers, instead of going against them.

Reply to this comment    20 November 1998, 07:36 GMT


Re: Re: Re: Article: "Put the Calculator Away!"
Olathe  Account Info
(Web Page)

It is not their job to make us want to do anything. They are not there to attempt to force us to form opinions about learning or anything else. There sole purpose is to ensure that we have a basic understanding of what they are teaching.

Reply to this comment    19 August 1999, 10:02 GMT


Re: Re: Article: Put the Calculator Away!
German Kuznetsov  Account Info

Thay had BS back then?

Reply to this comment    11 April 2014, 21:55 GMT

1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  

You can change the number of comments per page in Account Preferences.

  Copyright © 1996-2012, the ticalc.org project. All rights reserved. | Contact Us | Disclaimer